In an interview with Digital Spy, Javicia Leslie shared where she hoped "Batwoman" would next take her character. "Obviously, the fans would love to see more Wildmoore, which is Sophie and Ryan," said Leslie, referencing her character's romantic relationship with Sophie Moore (Meagan Tandy). "I think Meagan and I would also love to continue to play that love story. We'd love to see Mary and Luke maybe spark something. I also would love to see what's going to happen with Alice. What we were blessed with was the ability to create a beautiful finale that, whether we came back or not, is very satisfying for all of us."

For those unfamiliar, Alice aka Elizabeth Marie Kane (Rachel Skarsten) was a serial killer and the estranged, fraternal twin of Kate Kane (Ruby Rose, and then later Wallis Day). The character served as both an enemy and an ally, depending on the moment. Leslie went on to praise Skarsten for her performance, and said she's done a phenomenal job "playing every part of Alice and Beth." Leslie went on to say that she was aware of the fan's desire for "Batwoman" to return and that, should it ever come to fruition, she would happily follow suit. 

Leslie's aspirations for the fourth season were probably close to the money, as showrunner Caroline Dries spoke at length with Entertainment Weekly about how much emotional energy she invested into writing the relationship between Wilder and Moore. In Dries' mind, though, the primary focus was Wilder's relationship to Gotham, which she believed was a facet in earnest need of exploration.